Ok, I'm looking at a '95 M3. It has 73000 miles and 2k left on a warranty. He's the second owner, has all records, always diligently maintained. The car has 2 or 3 stone chips and one ding, and needs a new rubber front spoiler. That's all it needs. The guy was asking $23,900. I told him his price was not in line with the market. He acknowledged this, and refused my offer of $20,750. He offered $22,000. The car is really in immaculate cosmetic condition, and, pending a dealer pre-purchase inspection, likely mechanically just as good. Is he still way out of the ball park or is his offer reasonable?